Syllabus

Schedule

Resources

Other links

Literature Search Guide

Primary vs. Secondary Sources

In scientific writing, authors cite findings from previous researchers to provide a foundation for their rationale, give credit for developing of a procedure, validate their research findings, or stress the significance of the research topic. Regardless of purpose, the primary research article is the most frequently cited form of publication.

Secondary sources

Secondary sources summarize or comment on data that were presented in primary sources. Because secondary sources include public interest pieces in commercial magazines as well as review articles published in scientific journals, the intended audience may be general or specific. Like primary sources, secondary sources may have figures and tables; however, in secondary sources these elements are used to summarize or show examples of research from the cited primary sources. While not the preferred source for most citations, scientific review articles do cite many primary sources that may be useful.

Citing sources

Almost all citations in a scientific paper refer the reader to the primary source. Review articles intended for a specialized scientific audience are cited on occasion when the topic has been covered in many relevant primary sources. Still, if one primary source can be singled out as the seminal work on the topic, it should be cited. For example, many research papers may have followed a pioneering paper by Smith in 1998. If Johnson later reviewed this field in 2006, an author might cite this as (Smith, 1998; reviewed in Johnson, 2006).

Searching for Sources

Online tools to search scientific databases are easily accessible. Articles are archived with keywords to aid in searching. Scientific databases can be general or specialized in particular subjects. In the next section, this handout describes one widely used general subject database, PubMed. In addition, recent upgrades to Google search such as Google Scholar have made it increasingly easy to locate primary sources. Many journals have content available online, which may be article abstracts or full articles. Articles are frequently archived and stored as downloadable PDFs. Most journal sites with full article access require that you or your institution have an online subscription.

PubMed

PubMed (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed) is sponsored by the National Library of Medicine and contains citation listings for for biomedical and life science journals as early as the 1950s. Clicking on one of the search results usually retrieves the article abstract and links to the full text from the journal’s website, if available at your institution. Advanced search features are also available to limit your search by author name, journal title, keyword, or dates of publication.

Google Scholar

Google (www.google.com) can search for scholarly articles from academic publishers, professional societies, and university presses that are related to your topic.  Under the “more” tab at the top of the Google search page, select “Scholar” to use this search function. Clicking “Advanced Scholar Search” to the right of the input field allows you to use more detailed search criteria based on author, journal or publication title, or a selected date range. In the search results, articles with the note “Full Text @ Fondren” have full content available online for those connected via Rice computers.

Choosing Search Terms

The search terms you choose will influence the quality of your results. Selecting broad search terms may retrieve all of the articles that you are interested in, but you may waste time sorting through articles that are not related to your specific project. Selecting search terms that are too specific may mean that you miss important articles. Both broad and specific searches are useful, but you need to consider what type and number of sources you will find. For example, if you are interested in studying scent in rose plants and want to know if scent strength follows a circadian rhythm, you might search for “circadian rhythm,” but animals have circadian rhythms too! In fact, it is likely that none of the search results on the first page are even about plants. Perhaps you search “circadian rhythm rose.” Rose can mean a rose plant, but it also may mean rose colored, or it could be an author’s last name. Many of these results won’t be related to your topic. You might search “circadian rhythm rose plant scent” to retrieve specific results, but your source choices will be very limited. Frequently knowledge about one plant gives us clues about others. A search using “circadian rhythm plant scent” would return results limited to studies using plants, some of which probably relate to your work. Using advanced search options to limit your search to specific publication dates, journals, or authors can help refine your search within a selected topic. Keep in mind that recent articles are usually listed near the top of the results. Limiting the dates of publication may help you locate the early publications that provided the foundation for current research.

Copyright and Intended Use
Visitors: to ensure that your message is not mistaken for SPAM, please include the acronym "Bios211" in the subject line of e-mail communications
Created by David R. Caprette (caprette@rice.edu), Rice University 17 Aug 08
Authored by Elizabeth Eich, Ph.D., Rice University